BMW X3 vs Mercedes-Benz

When comparing the BMW X3 and Mercedes-Benz, it’s important to specify which Mercedes-Benz model you’re interested in, as Mercedes-Benz offers several SUVs that could be considered rivals to the X3. The most direct competitor to the BMW X3 is generally the Mercedes-Benz GLC. Other Mercedes-Benz SUVs like the GLB and GLA are typically smaller and might be compared to the BMW X1 or X2.

Here’s a breakdown comparing the BMW X3 primarily with the Mercedes-Benz GLC, and briefly touching on other models:

BMW X3 vs. Mercedes-Benz GLC
These two are fierce rivals in the compact luxury SUV segment. Both offer a blend of performance, luxury, and practicality.

Key Comparison Points:

Driving Dynamics:

BMW X3: Traditionally, BMWs are known for their sporty and engaging driving experience. The X3 often features a more agile feel and a steering that is light but still keen to turn into corners, making it feel more dynamic. Its engines are often eager to deliver power throughout the rev range.

Mercedes-Benz GLC: The GLC tends to prioritize refinement, comfort, and a cohesive driving feel with a greater uniformity of weight and responsiveness. While still capable, it generally leans more towards a smooth and luxurious ride. The mild-hybrid systems in some GLC engines are particularly refined, making start/stop cycles nearly imperceptible.

Interior and Technology:

BMW X3: Recent X3 models boast a twin-curved screen setup with a 12.3-inch driver’s display and a 14.9-inch touchscreen infotainment unit. It uses BMW’s iDrive system, known for its rotary controller. Build quality is generally excellent.

Mercedes-Benz GLC: The GLC often takes the lead in interior luxury and technology, especially after its 2023 redesign. It features a 12.3-inch digital driver’s display and a prominent 11.9-inch portrait touchscreen infotainment unit. The interior materials, such as open-pore wood trim, can feel more opulent. The MBUX infotainment system is highly regarded.

Ergonomics: Some reviews suggest the GLC is easier to get comfortable in, while the X3’s tall dashboard might require a taller seating position for some drivers.

Space and Practicality:

BMW X3: Offers good space for passengers and cargo. Boot space is around 570 liters (1,700 liters with rear seats down) for fuel-powered models.

Mercedes-Benz GLC: Generally offers slightly more rear legroom due to a longer wheelbase, despite being similar in overall length. The GLC also boasts a larger boot space (around 620 liters for petrol/diesel models), though plug-in hybrid models might have slightly less.

Engines and Performance:

Both offer a range of petrol, diesel, and plug-in hybrid (PHEV) options.

BMW X3: Known for its potent engines, including a 2.0-liter 4-cylinder and a 3.0-liter 6-cylinder. The X3 M40i, for example, offers strong performance.

Mercedes-Benz GLC: Also offers 2.0-liter 4-cylinder engines, often paired with mild-hybrid systems for improved efficiency. High-performance AMG variants are available, offering impressive power.

Pricing:

Pricing can vary significantly based on trim levels, options, and region. Generally, they are very competitively priced, with slight variations depending on specific configurations.

Design:

BMW X3: Has a more athletic and “chunky” look with sharper lines and BMW’s signature kidney grille.

Mercedes-Benz GLC: Presents a more elegant, curvier, and sophisticated design, often described as a “mini-me GLC” for its resemblance to larger Mercedes SUVs.

BMW X3 vs. Mercedes-Benz GLB
The GLB is a more compact SUV than the X3, but it offers a unique selling point: optional third-row seating, which the X3 does not.

Size: The X3 is generally longer and wider than the GLB.

Seating: GLB offers 5 or 7 seats, while the X3 is strictly a 5-seater.

Driving Feel: The X3 typically offers a more powerful and engaging driving experience due to its larger engines and platform. The GLB is more focused on versatility and practicality.

Price: The GLB is usually more affordable than the X3.

BMW X3 vs. Mercedes-Benz GLA
The GLA is Mercedes-Benz’s smallest SUV and is a direct competitor to the BMW X1, not the X3.

Size: The GLA is significantly smaller than the X3 in terms of length, width, and cargo capacity.

Class: The X3 is a compact luxury SUV, while the GLA is a subcompact luxury SUV.

Performance: The X3 generally offers more powerful engine options and a more substantial driving feel.

Price: The GLA is considerably less expensive than the X3.

In summary:

If you’re looking for a direct comparison to the BMW X3, the Mercedes-Benz GLC is the model to consider. The choice between them often comes down to a preference for driving dynamics (X3’s sportiness vs. GLC’s refinement), interior aesthetics and technology, and subtle differences in practicality. If you need optional seven-seater capability in a slightly smaller package, the Mercedes-Benz GLB becomes a relevant alternative, but it’s not a direct competitor in the same class as the X3.

Sources